Главная страница
russian   english
16+
<< back

Title of Article

ON THE ISSUE OF THE ADMISSIBILITY OF THE USE OF NUCLEAR WEAPONS (BASED ON THE MATERIALS OF THE ADVISORY OPINION OF THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE)


Issue
4
Date
2011

Article type
scientific article
UDC
341.1/8
Pages
265-268
Keywords
nuclear weapons, Advisory Opinion, International Court of Justice, preamble of international legal acts


Authors
Meleshnikov Alevtin Vasilevich
Nizhegorodskiy gosuniversitet im. N.I. Lobachevskogo


Abstract
The problem of the admissibility of the application of nuclear weapons is considered by means of analyzing the materials contained in the Advisory Opinion of the International Court of Justice dated July 19, 1996. The author shows that the Court, having ignored the analysis of preambles of international legal acts, has come to the conclusion that the current international law does not forbid the application of nuclear weapons in an extreme case of self-defence. On the contrary, the only judge whose system of argumentation included an analysis of the provisions contained in the preambles, proved that all types of weapons of mass destruction had been forbidden as early as at the end of the 19th century. The author shares this legal opinion and arrives at a generalising corollary on the necessity for such an issue as «the preambles of legal acts» to be considered by the United Nations International Law Commission as one of primary importance.

File (in Russian)